Skip to main content
Results & Research

Research Index

Search every Applied Research Center study, research brief, and case study, including peer-reviewed journal articles, by product, school level, state, student group, outcome, or status.

Find Research by Product, Place, or Student Group

Applied Research Center studies, research briefs, and case studies by product, status, sample, location, and key finding
StudyYearStatusProductsSample and designWhereKey finding
Peer-reviewed journal article
The Indirect Effects of Leadership Style on Teacher Innovation Adoption Mediated by Autonomy Satisfaction, Frustration and Innovativeness
Basileo, L. D., Lyons, M. E., Toth, M. D., Otto, B., & Hofmann, F. · Discover Education

A peer-reviewed longitudinal study of 422 teachers in 41 elementary, middle, and high schools in 11 districts across seven states. Each of four leadership styles had a significant indirect effect on teachers’ adoption of an instructional innovation through autonomy satisfaction, autonomy frustration, and teacher innovativeness.

2026PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning422 teachers who completed both survey waves, 41 schools, 11 districts
Design: Longitudinal two-wave teacher survey; multilevel structural equation modeling
States: Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Texas, West Virginia
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Teacher innovativeness had the strongest positive association with adoption of the innovation, regardless of leadership style, teacher autonomy, or years of experience; supportive leadership styles fostered adoption and restrictive, hierarchical styles hindered it.
Research brief
ESSA Tier 2: Moderate evidence
Double-Digit ELA and Math Gains Associated with the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning
Basileo, L. D., Instructional Empowerment Applied Research Center

A pilot study in Colorado Springs School District 11 compared students of teachers verified in the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® with matched comparison students using the same curriculum, adjusting for fall achievement and student characteristics. The sample includes a turnaround school.

2026PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool TurnaroundELA: 357 students (195 verified, 162 comparison), 18 teacher-grade clusters. Math: 449 students (237 / 212), 20 clusters. Grades 2–11.
Design: Quasi-experimental; matched comparison teacher-grade clusters; baseline covariate adjustment; multilevel models
States: Colorado
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Students of verified teachers scored 22.44 STAR points higher in ELA (p = .045) and 18.24 points higher in math (p = .011), about 55% and 35% of typical annual growth.
Research brief
ESSA Tier 3: Promising evidence
RigorWalk and Achievement: Evidence from the Applied Research Center
Instructional Empowerment Applied Research Center

A study of 82 schools in 12 districts found that schools with higher RigorWalk scores had larger gains in ELA and math proficiency within a single school year.

2026PublishedRigorWalk82 schools, 12 districts, 9 states
Design: Structural equation modeling; controls for socioeconomic status and English learner status
States: Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Oklahoma, Texas, West Virginia
School levels: Pre-K, Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Higher RigorWalk scores predicted 4–5 percentage-point gains in ELA proficiency and 5–6 points in math within one school year.
Case study
How Cedar Rapids Community School District Transformed Student Achievement in One Year
Instructional Empowerment

In one year of districtwide implementation, Cedar Rapids improved proficiency and attendance, and i-Ready learning rates exceeded national norms by 25% (K–5) and 83% (grades 6–8) in math.

2026PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool TurnaroundRigorWalk31 schools; 14,729 students; 4,962 RigorWalks
Design: Descriptive case study using public district and state data
States: Iowa
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: Black students, Hispanic students, English learners, Students with disabilities, Low-income students
Districtwide, math proficiency rose 5.3 points and ELA proficiency rose 2.5 points in one year, with significant gap closures among student groups. In the turnaround schools studied, chronic absenteeism fell 9.2 percentage points on average.
Case study
How Cedar Rapids Raised Rigor and Student Achievement in One Year
Instructional Empowerment

A RigorWalk-focused account of the Cedar Rapids Community School District results.

2026PublishedRigorWalk31 schools
Design: Descriptive case study
States: Iowa
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: Black students, English learners, Students with disabilities
RigorWalk indicators grew 40% for learning targets, 50% for evidence of student learning, and 33% for student teaming alongside districtwide proficiency gains.
Report with original data
Rapid and Sustainable School Turnaround: Case Study Evidence
Instructional Empowerment

A synthesis of turnaround case studies across three states.

2026PublishedSchool Turnaround9 Florida turnaround schools (2017–22) plus Iowa and Indiana examples
Design: Descriptive case study synthesis using public state data
States: Florida, Indiana, Iowa
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: Black students, Hispanic students, Students with disabilities, Low-income students
State accountability scores improved at all nine Florida turnaround schools studied; Putnam County’s graduation rate rose from 54.9% to 96.6%.
Journal article (accepted)
Autonomy-Supportive Leadership and Teacher Burnout: A Multilevel Motivational Model of Direct and Indirect Effects Through Autonomy Frustration
Lyons, M. E., Basileo, L. D., Otto, B., & Toth, M. D. · Journal of Educational Psychology

A two-wave study extending autonomy-supportive teaching theory to school leadership. Autonomy frustration, not satisfaction, carried the indirect effect on burnout.

Accepted for publication; link to be added when published.
2026AcceptedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning570 teachers (from 1,326 staff; 82% and 74% response by wave) in 42 schools, 8 districts, 7 states (waves 1 and 2)
Design: Two-wave survey; multilevel structural equation modeling
States: Arizona, Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, North Carolina, West Virginia
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Autonomy-supportive leadership predicted lower autonomy frustration (β = −.32), higher satisfaction (β = .35), and lower burnout (direct β = −.13); the indirect effect ran through frustration (β = −.20).
Journal article (accepted)
A Key to Unlocking Reform in Education: Autonomy-Supportive Leadership and Teacher Innovativeness
Basileo, L. D., Lyons, M. E., Toth, M. D., Otto, B., Carmignola, M., & Hofmann, F. · International Journal of Leadership in Education

A survey of 1,408 teachers in 71 low-performing schools in 11 districts found that teacher innovativeness and autonomy-supportive leadership were associated with implementation of an instructional innovation. Also presented at the American Educational Research Association annual meeting in 2025.

Accepted for publication on October 15, 2026; link to be added when published.
2026AcceptedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning1,408 teachers in 71 low-performing schools in 11 districts in seven U.S. states
Design: Cross-sectional survey
States: Seven states (names not specified)
School levels: Not reported
Student groups: None reported
Teacher innovativeness had the largest association with implementing the innovation; autonomy satisfaction and frustration were also significant, and leadership style effects were reduced after accounting for autonomy.
Research brief
Is the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning Linked to Higher Student Well-Being? An Applied Research Center Brief on Student-Led Team Learning
Instructional Empowerment Applied Research Center

A fall 2025 survey of 1,112 students found large associations among student-led team learning, autonomy satisfaction, and well-being.

2026PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool Turnaround1,112 students in 49 classrooms, grades 3-12 (wave 1 only; the peer-reviewed version uses waves 1 and 2)
Design: Cross-sectional survey (wave 1); correlations and multilevel structural equation modeling
States: Colorado
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Stronger student-led team learning was associated with higher student well-being (r = .594); autonomy satisfaction explained about 76% of the association.
Library article
School Improvement Success Stories: Four Schools, One Approach
Instructional Empowerment

A descriptive account of four schools that worked with Instructional Empowerment, including two South Bend, Indiana elementary schools whose IREAD-3 proficiency rose from 2021 (the year before the partnership began) to 2025.

2025PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningRigorWalk2 elementary schools (South Bend, IN), IREAD-3 proficiency, 2021 to 2025
Design: Descriptive account; public Indiana GPS data
States: Indiana
School levels: Elementary
Student groups: Black students, Hispanic students, English learners, Low-income students
Muessel Elementary IREAD-3 proficiency rose from 16.7% to 58.2% (+41.5 points) and Madison STEAM Academy from 35.8% to 72.7% (+36.9 points), 2021 to 2025; from 2024 to 2025, Black, Hispanic, English learner, and economically disadvantaged students posted gains of 12.2 to 25.8 points at the two schools.
Research brief
Applied Research Center Brief: Analyzing Chronic Absenteeism Rates in Schools Implementing the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning
Instructional Empowerment Applied Research Center

A study of 76 schools in 10 districts across 7 states. Reductions grew with each year of implementation (1.2 points in year 1, 5.2 in year 2, 6.0 in year 3).

2025PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning76 schools, 10 districts, 7 states
Design: Descriptive and correlational analysis of public state absenteeism data with school implementation scores
States: Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Texas, West Virginia
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: English learners, Low-income students
79% of implementing schools reduced chronic absenteeism (median 5.6 percentage points vs. 2 nationally); the top school reduced it by 20 points.
Research brief
Applied Research Center Brief: Reduced Teacher Burnout with a Model that Improves School Culture
Basileo, L. D.

A survey of 570 teachers found significantly lower burnout where the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® was more strongly implemented, with school culture also strongly related to burnout.

2025PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning570 teachers, 76 schools, 10 districts, 7 states (wave 1 only; the peer-reviewed version uses waves 1 and 2)
Design: Correlational survey study; structural equation modeling
States: Arizona, Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, West Virginia, North Carolina
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Higher implementation was associated with lower teacher burnout (r = –.38, p < .001); school culture was associated with lower burnout (r = –.53).
Research brief
Validated Impact: Linking Deeper Learning Professional Development to Student Achievement
Basileo, L. D.

A study of 6,200 elementary students in 318 Cedar Rapids classrooms found higher ELA scores for students whose teachers had made at least 70% progress toward the 101 Implement badge of the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning.

2025PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning6,200 students; 318 classrooms
Design: Multilevel model (students in classrooms) with baseline ELA and student controls
States: Iowa
School levels: Elementary
Student groups: None reported
Students whose teachers had made at least 70% progress toward the 101 Implement badge gained 4.38 more FAST ELA points than students whose teachers had made no progress (p = .04).
Library article
Why Students with Disabilities Are Still Left Out—And How to Change That with Deeper Learning
Toth, M. D., & Lyons, M. E.

An analysis of four districts (2023–25) found narrowing achievement gaps for students with disabilities.

2025PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning4 districts; counts not stated
Design: Descriptive gap-closure analysis across 4 districts, 2023–25
States: Iowa
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: Students with disabilities
Gaps for students with disabilities closed by up to 58% (ELA) and 90% (math) in elementary and 58% and 92% in middle grades; North High School special education graduation rose 16.42 points after one year.
Library article
English Learners Are Capable of More—If We Make the Shift to Deeper Learning
Toth, M. D., & Lyons, M. E., with Jessica Hessler

In partner schools, English learners closed the achievement gap with native English-speaking students, based on Applied Research Center analysis of 2023–2025 data from four districts.

2025PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning4 districts; counts not stated
Design: Descriptive gap-closure analysis across 4 districts, 2023–25
States: Not reported
School levels: Not reported
Student groups: English learners
English learners closed the achievement gap by 6–47% in English Language Arts and by 4–74% in math.
Case study
How Willard Elementary Climbed to #2 in ELA Growth and #9 in Math Among Illinois K–6 Schools
Instructional Empowerment

Over two years (2021–22 to 2023–24), Willard Elementary improved ELA and math proficiency, cut office-managed discipline referrals from 288 to 36, and reduced chronic absenteeism.

2025PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning1 school (K-6), 240 students, School District U-46, Illinois
Design: Descriptive case study
States: Illinois
School levels: Elementary
Student groups: English learners, Students with disabilities, Low-income students
ELA proficiency rose from 10.9% to 35% and math from 15.6% to 24.7%; ELA growth ranked #2 and math #9 among 107 Illinois K–6 schools; chronic absenteeism fell 6.6 points.
Report with original data
The School Turnaround Trap: Why Quick Fixes Fail Students
Toth, M. D., Fitzgerald, M., & Lyons, M. E.

A report on why quick-fix turnaround models fade, with original analysis of data collected from 39 turnaround schools.

2025PublishedSchool TurnaroundSchool Comprehensive Needs AssessmentRigor Appraisal383 classrooms in 39 turnaround schools
Design: Original Applied Research Center analysis of Rigor Appraisal classroom observation data
States: Arizona, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Texas
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
85% of observed classrooms in 39 turnaround schools had no evidence of student work or were at the lowest level of rigor.
Peer-reviewed journal article
An Exploratory Analysis of Early Adopters in Education Innovations
Basileo, L. D., & Lyons, M. E. · Quality Education for All, 1(1), 158–179

A peer-reviewed study of how teachers who adopt innovations early influence instructional change, using two cross-sectional teacher surveys and follow-up interviews. Teachers identified as Early Adopters were more likely to implement the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning, and satisfaction of teachers’ basic psychological needs was the strongest predictor of implementation.

2024PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning568 teachers in 18 schools in eight districts (School Culture Survey); 108 Early Adopter teachers surveyed; 16 interviewed
Design: Two cross-sectional teacher surveys plus follow-up interviews (16 teachers); hierarchical linear modeling to adjust for clustering of teachers within schools
States: Arizona, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Texas
School levels: Pre-K, Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Teachers identified as Early Adopters were significantly more likely to implement the innovation, and satisfaction of teachers' basic psychological needs was the strongest predictor of implementation.
Peer-reviewed journal article
The Role of Self-Efficacy, Motivation, and Perceived Support of Students’ Basic Psychological Needs in Academic Achievement
Basileo, L. D., Otto, B., Lyons, M., Vannini, N., & Toth, M. D. · Frontiers in Education, 9, 1385442

A peer-reviewed study of 2,359 middle school students in Germany. Self-efficacy was the strongest predictor of achievement and mediated the effect of autonomous motivation on grades, validating the student autonomy conditions the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® is designed to build.

2024PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning2,359 students in grades 5–9; 35 middle schools in 3 German states
Design: Cross-sectional survey; hierarchical linear modeling
States: International (Germany)
School levels: Middle
Student groups: None reported
Self-efficacy had the largest relationship with achievement (β = .49 in math, .40 in German).
Peer-reviewed journal article
ESSA Tier 3: Promising evidence
Leading Indicators of Academic Achievement: Investigating the Predictive Validity of an Observation Instrument in a Large District
Basileo, L. D., Lyons, M. E., & Toth, M. D. · SAGE Open, 14(2)

A peer-reviewed correlational study of 53 schools in one Illinois district that tested Rigor Appraisal as a leading indicator of student achievement, attendance, and behavior.

2024PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool Comprehensive Needs AssessmentRigor AppraisalRigorWalk53 schools in one Illinois district (about 35,000 students; 46.4% low-income, 39.1% English learners, 18.6% students with disabilities), 2021-22; 48 schools in the achievement analyses
Design: Correlational study with school-level regression; no comparison group
States: Illinois
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: English learners, Students with disabilities, Low-income students
Higher Rigor Appraisal scores were associated with higher ELA learning rates (r = .388), fewer behavior referrals (r = −.388) and suspensions (r = −.431), and higher climate scores. Attendance was positively associated but only approached significance (p = .073). More instructional classroom walks were associated with stronger math learning rates (r = .432). More coaching days were associated with significantly greater ELA gains (r = .356) and with math gains that approached significance (r = .280). Academic teaming predicted higher achievement in schools with more low-income students.
Case study
Stronger Together: A Review of How Two Schools Improved Instruction After Consolidating
Instructional Empowerment

Two Grand Island schools with very different starting points consolidated and implemented the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®. In 2020 they became Nebraska’s first Demonstration Schools for Rigor.

2024PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning2 schools
Design: Descriptive case study
States: Nebraska
School levels: Elementary
Student groups: Low-income students
Average gains from fall 2018 to spring 2019 were +9.51 in reading, +12.29 in math, and +3.20 in science; the schools started at 11% and 93% free/reduced lunch.
Case study
Woonsocket Education Department Boosts Student Engagement and Achievement Through Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning
Instructional Empowerment

A one-year pilot comparison in 6 classrooms. The sample is very small, so results should be read as an early signal.

2024PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning6 classrooms across 3 grade levels; district has 9 schools and 5,690 students
Design: Comparison of partner and non-partner classrooms (descriptive)
States: Rhode Island
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Partner classrooms’ RICAS ELA proficiency was 2.8–16.7 points higher and math 10–27 points higher than comparison classrooms across grade bands A–C.
Case study
William D. Moseley Elementary School, Palatka, FL: Becoming a School Where All Students Thrive
Instructional Empowerment

Moseley improved ELA and math proficiency, cut behavior referrals, and reduced teacher turnover.

2019PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool Turnaround1 school (K-5), 512 students, 35 core teachers, 2016-17 to 2018-19
Design: Descriptive case study
States: Florida
School levels: Elementary
Student groups: Black students, Students with disabilities, Low-income students, Students experiencing homelessness or in foster care
ELA proficiency rose from 18% to 38% and math from 28% to 41%; behavior referrals fell from 575 (2016-17) to 234 in year one and 236 in year two; teacher turnover fell from 56% to 17% over three years.
Case study
Lakewood Elementary: How This Florida School Raised Their State Rating From the Lowest to One of the Highest in the State
Instructional Empowerment

Lakewood moved from the state’s lowest accountability tier ("F") to its highest ("A") over three years.

2021PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool Turnaround1 school (K-5), 405 students, 33 core teachers, 2017-18 to 2020-21
Design: Descriptive case study
States: Florida
School levels: Elementary
Student groups: Black students, Students with disabilities, Low-income students, Students experiencing homelessness or in foster care
Math proficiency rose from 22% to 62% and ELA proficiency from 18% to 41%; the state accountability score rose from 23% to 70%; behavior referrals fell from 734 to 81 over three years; teacher turnover fell from 70% to 3%.
Case study
Lakewood Elementary: How This Florida School Substantially Outperformed Its District’s Learning Rates Through the Pandemic
Instructional Empowerment

During the 2020–21 year, Lakewood improved their learning rates while comparable schools declined. Lakewood also closed and narrowed achievement gaps in reading and math for various student groups and grade levels.

2021PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool Turnaround1 school (2020–21)
Design: Descriptive case study; learning rates compared with district
States: Florida
School levels: Elementary
Student groups: Black students, Students with disabilities, Low-income students
Lakewood increased its learning rate in math (48%) and reading (7%) while similar schools in the district decreased their learning rates. Lakewood outperformed the average across the entire district in both reading and math.
Case study
How McLaughlin Middle School Exited Comprehensive Support Status, Received Its Best Results in 7 Years, and Outperformed Its District Learning Rates
Instructional Empowerment

McLaughlin had its best results in seven years and left comprehensive support status.

2021PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningSchool Turnaround1 school (grades 6-8), 2019-20 to 2020-21
Design: Descriptive case study
States: Florida
School levels: Middle
Student groups: Black students, Hispanic students
The school exited Comprehensive Support and Improvement status and outperformed Polk County district averages by 13% in reading and 7% in math (Spring 2020-21 STAR). In reading, the Hispanic–non-Hispanic gap closed completely in grade 8 and by 93% in grade 7, and the Black–White gap closed by 35% in grade 7. In math, the Black–White gap closed by 84% in grade 7 and 90% in grade 8, and the Hispanic–non-Hispanic gap by 69% in grade 7.
Research report
How a Great City School District Is Improving Performance and Closing Achievement Gaps for All Students: A 10,000-Student Study of Des Moines Public Schools
Basileo, L. D.

A research report on 22 Des Moines demonstration schools, using matched comparison students. Demonstration school students gained the equivalent of extra days of learning in reading and math, and achievement gaps narrowed for Black students, students with disabilities, and English learners.

Evidence note: Met What Works Clearinghouse Design Standards with Reservations
2019PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning22 demonstration schools; 10,431 students; about 890 teachers
Design: Quasi-experimental; propensity score matching and hierarchical linear modeling
States: Iowa
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: Black students, English learners, Students with disabilities
Over 162 school days, students gained 11 extra days of reading and 6 extra days of math; high schoolers gained 61 and 42 days; Black–White gaps closed 7% (reading) and 6% (math).
Case study
Walnut Middle School, Grand Island, NE: Transforming Student Behavior
Instructional Empowerment

Walnut Middle School saw fewer discipline referrals and more positive recognitions in one year.

2018PublishedModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning1 school; 771 students; 46 teachers (2017–18)
Design: Descriptive case study
States: Nebraska
School levels: Middle
Student groups: English learners, Students with disabilities, Low-income students
Discipline referrals fell 37% (777 to 489) in the first year and positive behavior recognitions rose from 90 to 272.
Conference paper
Turning Around Chronically Low-Performing Schools
Basileo, L. D., & Toth, M. · American Educational Research Association annual meeting, San Antonio, Texas (paper repository)

A conference paper on 10 chronically low-performing Florida schools that received intensive professional development and coaching for teachers and principals, with specific and actionable feedback. Presented at the American Educational Research Association annual meeting.

2017PublishedSchool Turnaround10 Florida schools (7 elementary, 1 middle, 1 high, 1 combined middle and high), 2014-15 to 2015-16; 131 tested teachers in 2014-15 and 103 in 2015-16; 67 treatment and 67 matched comparison teachers
Design: Quasi-experimental: t-tests, propensity score matching, hierarchical linear modeling; outcome is teacher value-added
States: Florida
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: Low-income students
Three schools gained two letter grades, four gained one, and three stayed the same; teachers in treatment schools had value-added scores .199 higher than matched teachers one year later (p = .008).
Research brief
Marquardt School District 15 i-Ready learning rates and subgroup gap closure
Basileo, L. D., & Lyons, M. E.

Whole-school implementation coincided with learning rates at or above national i-Ready norms, strongest in math, and with narrowing gaps for English learners, students with disabilities, and low-income students.

Research brief to be published on the Instructional Empowerment library.
—Upcoming briefModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning5 schools (grades K–8), 2,013 students; whole-school implementation, 2025–26
Design: Norm-referenced comparison to national i-Ready norms; subgroup gap analysis; no comparison group
States: Illinois
School levels: Elementary, Middle
Student groups: English learners, Students with disabilities
Math learning rates exceeded national norms at every grade (weighted +80% in K–5, +123% in grades 6–8); ELA was +41% in grades 6–8 and equal to the norm in K–5.
Journal manuscript
RigorWalk and Student Achievement: How Non-Evaluative Instructional Walks Shape Leader Effectiveness Mental Models to Drive Inquiry
Basileo, L. D., Choi, H., & Toth, M. D.

A study of 78 schools found that school leadership teams’ shared perceptions of instruction, developed through RigorWalk, were associated with higher math and ELA proficiency.

Not yet published; no public link.
—Under reviewRigorWalk78 schools in 10 districts in nine states
Design: School-level confirmatory factor analysis and structural equation modeling, accounting for clustering
States: Nine states (names not specified)
School levels: Pre-K, Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Greater RigorWalk change scores were associated with higher math (β = .343, p = .016) and ELA proficiency (β = .283, p = .039).
Conference submission
Beyond the Traditional Salary Schedule: Pilot Evidence from an Autonomy-Supportive, Competency-Based Career Ladder for Teacher Growth and Student Learning
Basileo, L. D., Toth, M. D., & Lyons, M. E. · Submitted to the 2027 Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association (Vancouver)

A pilot study of whether verified teacher certification based on demonstrated instructional expertise is associated with student achievement.

Not yet published; no public link.
—Under reviewModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning357 students in ELA and 449 in math, from the Colorado Springs School District 11 pilot
Design: Not yet public.
States: Colorado
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Findings not yet public.
Journal manuscript
Student Teaming and Autonomy Satisfaction as Drivers of Well-Being in Deeper Learning Environments
Basileo, L. D., Lyons, M. E., Toth, M. D., & Otto, B.

A two-wave extension of the Colorado Springs School District 11 well-being research brief. Team learning predicted both autonomy satisfaction and agentic engagement, which each predicted higher well-being.

Not yet published; no public link.
—In progressModel of Instruction for Deeper LearningWaves 1 and 2: wave 1 (fall 2025) 1,119 students and 49 teachers; wave 2 (spring 2026) 1,193 students and 40 teachers
Design: Two-wave student survey; multilevel structural equation modeling (parallel mediation)
States: Colorado
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Autonomy satisfaction and agentic engagement fully mediated the link between team learning and spring well-being, explaining 83% of the variance in spring well-being.
Journal manuscript
Building School Capacity Through Autonomy-Supportive Leadership: Student-Led Team Learning and Parent Involvement
Basileo, L. D., Lin, J., Toth, M. D., Lyons, M. E., & Ratelle, C. F.

A longitudinal study of 948 teachers in 53 schools. Leadership continuity and team learning continuity carried the effects, and results held across alternative model specifications.

Not yet published; no public link.
—In progressModel of Instruction for Deeper Learning948 teachers in 53 schools, 8 educational organizations, 7 states
Design: Two-wave survey; longitudinal structural equation modeling
States: Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, North Carolina, West Virginia
School levels: Elementary, Middle, High
Student groups: None reported
Autonomy-supportive leadership predicted sustained student-led team learning and both school- and home-based parent involvement over the school year.
Definitions

How to Read This Index

Status

Published
The study is publicly available. Journal articles are published after outside peer review.
Accepted
A journal has accepted the article for publication; it is not yet published.
Upcoming brief
A research brief that is scheduled for publication on the Instructional Empowerment library.
Under review
The manuscript has been submitted to a journal or conference and is awaiting review.
In progress
The study is being conducted or written.

Evidence type

Peer-reviewed journal article
Published in a journal after outside review. This is the only type this index calls peer reviewed.
Research brief and research report
Written by the Applied Research Center and published by Instructional Empowerment. They have not been peer reviewed.
Case study
A description of one school or district’s results using public or partner data.
Conference paper and conference submission
A paper presented at, or submitted to, a research conference. Not a journal article.
Every Student Succeeds Act

Evidence Level by Product

The highest Every Student Succeeds Act evidence level supported for each Instructional Empowerment product, with the study that supports it.

Highest Every Student Succeeds Act evidence level supported for each Instructional Empowerment product
ProductEvidence levelSupporting study
Model of Instruction for Deeper LearningTier 2: Moderate evidenceDouble-Digit ELA and Math Gains Associated with the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning
Quasi-experimental study with matched comparison students in Colorado Springs School District 11.
School TurnaroundTier 2: Moderate evidenceDouble-Digit ELA and Math Gains Associated with the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning
The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® is part of School Turnaround, and the study sample includes a turnaround school.
School Comprehensive Needs AssessmentTier 3: Promising evidenceLeading Indicators of Academic Achievement
Correlational study in 53 Illinois schools, published in SAGE Open.
Rigor AppraisalTier 3: Promising evidenceLeading Indicators of Academic Achievement
Same SAGE Open study, which tested Rigor Appraisal as a leading indicator of achievement.
RigorWalkTier 3: Promising evidenceRigorWalk and Achievement: Evidence from the Applied Research Center
Structural equation model of 82 schools in 12 districts across nine states.

Every Student Succeeds Act tiers: Tier 1, strong evidence; Tier 2, moderate evidence; Tier 3, promising evidence; Tier 4, demonstrates a rationale. The Applied Research Center reports the highest tier each product’s studies support. Source: ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/essa

Common questions

Questions About the Research Index

Which studies are peer reviewed?

Four published journal articles have been peer reviewed: Quality Education for All (2024), Frontiers in Education (2024), SAGE Open (2024), and Discover Education (2026). An article in the Journal of Educational Psychology has been accepted and is forthcoming. Research briefs, reports, and case studies are produced by the Applied Research Center and are not peer reviewed.

How do I find research on a state, school level, or student group?

Use the filters above the table. Filter by State to see studies in a specific state, by School level to see Pre-K, elementary, middle, or high school studies, and by Student group to see studies on English learners, students with disabilities, low-income students, or Black and Hispanic students.

What do the status labels mean?

Published studies are publicly available. Accepted means a journal has accepted the article for publication. Upcoming brief means a research brief is scheduled for publication. Under review means a manuscript has been submitted and is awaiting review. In progress means the study is still being conducted or written.

What Every Student Succeeds Act evidence level does each product support?

The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning and School Turnaround support Tier 2, moderate evidence. School Comprehensive Needs Assessment, Rigor Appraisal, and RigorWalk support Tier 3, promising evidence.