Standalone or integratedESSA Tier 3 (Promising Evidence) is one of the evidence levels set by the Every Student Succeeds Act. It means at least one well-designed correlational study, with statistical controls for other factors, found a significant positive relationship between the program and student outcomes.
Know if instruction is on track, validated by research.
School leaders cannot afford to wait for annual accountability results to determine whether instructional improvement efforts are working. Rigor Appraisal® provides an objective, research-validated measure of instructional rigor three times each year, helping leaders identify trends, monitor progress, and adjust support before critical testing and accountability milestones.
Research-validated evidence of instructional rigor across the school
Objective baseline and growth measures to track improvement over time
Actionable insights that help leaders focus coaching and professional learning
Early indicators of progress toward school improvement and accountability goals
What does the research say about Rigor Appraisal®?
AchievementHigher ELA learning rates
AttendanceHigher weekly attendance
Referrals/SuspensionsImproved student behavior
School cultureStronger climate scores
In 53 Illinois schools, higher Rigor Appraisal® scores were associated with higher student achievement, attendance, and school climate and were associated with fewer referrals and suspensions.
Meets ESSA Tier 3 (Promising Evidence) criteria
Research led by Lindsey Devers Basileo, Ph.D., a U.S. Department of Education What Works Clearinghouse certified reviewer who directs our Applied Research Center.
“What we’re seeing is that there is a direct correlation between the Rigor Appraisal score and what we see in terms of student achievement. That gives us confidence in the tool. It also allows us as a school district to be predictive in terms of what we expect to see with student outcomes and make mid-year corrections.”
Troy KnodererChief Academic Officer, MSD Lawrence Township, IN
How it works
How does Rigor Appraisal® work?
1
Measure
A certified Rigor Appraisal® scorer visits at least 10 randomly selected classrooms and evaluates instructional rigor using research-validated indicators. The result is an objective picture of schoolwide instructional practices rather than isolated classroom observations.
2
Understand
Leaders review the findings with their scorer to understand current levels of instructional rigor, identify systemic barriers to improvement, and establish a baseline for measuring future growth.
3
Improve
Leaders use the findings to focus coaching, professional learning, and instructional priorities. Ongoing appraisals help measure progress, validate improvement efforts, and ensure changes in classroom practice are producing results.
Track it in Empowerment Central
Ongoing tracking of Rigor Appraisal results, with summary dashboards you can view by school, level, grade, or subject.
Yes. It stands on its own, and it also works alongside our other products.
Standalone
On its own
Establish a research-validated baseline of instructional rigor and cognitive engagement across classrooms followed by periodic benchmarks. Receive actionable findings and leadership debriefs that help prioritize improvement efforts and track growth over time.
Companion tool
With RigorWalk®
Combine frequent instructional walkthroughs with an independent appraisal of classroom rigor. Together, these tools provide both ongoing visibility and objective validation of instructional improvement efforts.
Included in every School Comprehensive Needs Assessment as a research-validated metric on instructional effectiveness. Identify the instructional factors contributing most to student outcomes. When combined with surveys, interviews, and other diagnostic measures, Rigor Appraisal® helps uncover root causes and prioritize improvement strategies.
Establish a clear picture of instructional strengths and challenges at the start of the turnaround process. Rigor Appraisal® provides objective benchmarks that help leaders measure implementation progress and demonstrate impact over time.
Rigor Appraisal® is a non-evaluative metric conducted three times per year by certified scorers to measure the effectiveness of instructional systems across a school. It provides an objective third-party assessment of rigorous, standards-aligned Tier 1 instruction, showing whether the school is making measurable progress toward school improvement or state accountability goals, so leaders can act before spring.
How is Rigor Appraisal® different from RigorWalk®?
RigorWalk® is a frequent classroom walkthrough process run by school leaders, district leaders, and/or coaches using a shared rubric focused on student evidence of learning. Rigor Appraisal® is an appraisal conducted three times per year by certified scorers. The two share the same research base: RigorWalk® gives leaders immediate data they can act on, and Rigor Appraisal® provides an objective check that confirms it and shows whether walkthrough data align.
Who conducts a Rigor Appraisal®?
Instructional Empowerment’s certified scorers, who are leadership coaches, conduct it. To become certified, they must complete a 6-hour training course, practice scoring, participate in calibration sessions in schools to ensure rater reliability, and be accompanied by experienced master scorers on their first data collection cycle. Because scorers are external to the school, they provide an objective, third-party view.
What happens during a Rigor Appraisal®, and are teachers evaluated?
The scorer meets onsite with the leadership team, conducts interviews to capture schoolwide trends, and jointly scores at least 10 randomly selected classrooms. They then debrief, identify baseline conditions and systems-based root causes, and determine next steps for improvement. Teachers are not evaluated: Rigor Appraisal® collects schoolwide trend data, not data on individual teachers.
Are students tested?
No. Rigor Appraisal® does not test students. Select students are interviewed to capture data on the impact of systems on students. The scorer visits at least 10 randomly selected classrooms and scores based on observable indicators, so results reflect schoolwide trends.
What does the research say about Rigor Appraisal®?
In a peer-reviewed study of 53 schools published in SAGE Open (2024), higher Rigor Appraisal® scores were associated with higher ELA achievement (math trended in the same direction), higher attendance, fewer behavior referrals and suspensions, and stronger school climate. The study covered one Illinois district in 2021–22, and the authors call for further study in other settings.
Does Rigor Appraisal® meet ESSA evidence standards?
Yes. Rigor Appraisal® meets ESSA Tier 3 (Promising Evidence) criteria. The research was led by Lindsey Devers Basileo, Ph.D., a U.S. Department of Education What Works Clearinghouse certified reviewer.
Can we use Rigor Appraisal® without other Instructional Empowerment products?
Talk with an experienced education leader about an objective baseline for your school or district, whether on its own or alongside RigorWalk®, a needs assessment, or a turnaround partnership.
Talk with expert career educators, not salespeople
Hear how it works and best practices for implementation